Subscribe for real-time financial insights on Trade Target’s WhatsApp Channels
Not every investment strategy is designed for the long term. Short-term trading focuses on capturing price movements within a limited time frame and can be rewarding when done with discipline and risk control. Two common short-term trading methods are intraday trading and option trading. While both aim for quick gains, they work very differently and carry different risk levels. To understand option trading vs intraday trading, let’s begin with option trading.
What Is Options Trading?
Options trading involves buying or selling contracts that give the trader the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an underlying asset at a fixed price before a specified expiry date. The key difference from direct trading is flexibility, you can choose whether or not to execute the trade.
In options, you pay a small amount, called a premium, to lock in a future price. If the trade works in your favour, you benefit. If it doesn’t, your loss is limited to the premium paid.
- Call Options: A call option gives the buyer the right to purchase an asset at a fixed price (called the strike price) before the contract expires. To get this right, the buyer pays a premium.
- Call Buying: Suppose a stock is trading at ₹820. You expect the price to rise and buy a call option with a strike price of ₹830 by paying a premium of ₹15 per share.
- If the stock moves to ₹880 before expiry, the option gains value and you profit after adjusting for the premium paid.
- If the stock does not cross the strike price, the option expires worthless.
- The maximum loss for the buyer is limited to the premium paid.
- Call buying is often used when traders expect a strong upward move with limited downside risk.
- Call Selling: When you sell a call option, you receive the premium upfront, but you take on the obligation to sell the asset at the strike price if the buyer chooses to exercise the option.
- If the stock price stays below the strike price until expiry, the option expires worthless and the seller keeps the premium.
- If the stock price rises sharply above the strike price, the seller’s losses increase as prices rise.
- Since there is no limit to how high a stock price can go, call selling carries unlimited risk and requires high capital, margin, and strict risk management.
- Put Options: A put option gives the buyer the right to sell an asset at a fixed price before expiry, in exchange for a premium.
- Put Buying: Assume a stock is trading at ₹1,200. You expect the price to fall and buy a put option with a strike price of ₹1,200 by paying a premium of ₹25 per share.
- If the stock falls to ₹1,100, the put option gains value and you profit after adjusting for the premium.
- If the stock rises instead, the put expires worthless.
- The maximum loss remains limited to the premium paid.
- Put buying is commonly used to profit from falling markets or to hedge an existing portfolio.
- Put Selling: In put selling, the trader earns the premium upfront and agrees to buy the asset at the strike price if the buyer exercises the option.
- If the stock stays above the strike price, the seller keeps the premium.
- If the stock falls sharply, the seller is forced to buy the stock at a higher price, leading to losses.
- While put selling has limited profit potential, losses can be significant if the stock price drops heavily. This is why SEBI mandates SPAN and exposure margin for option sellers.
What is Intraday Trading?
Intraday trading involves buying and selling shares on the same trading day. All positions must be closed before the market shuts, usually around 3:15 PM. Since positions are not carried overnight, intraday traders rely purely on same-day price movements.
On the other hand, if the price drops to ₹212 and you choose not to exit, the broker will automatically close the position before market close.Â
This is mandatory because intraday trades cannot be carried forward to the next day. Price movements within a single day are usually limited, which is why brokers offer intraday margin to increase trading exposure.
Role of Margin in Intraday Trading
Margin is a form of leverage provided by brokers. For example, if you have ₹20,000 in your trading account and the broker offers 4× leverage, you can take positions worth up to ₹80,000. This increases both profits and losses.
If the stock price rises, profits grow faster due to higher exposure. However, if the price moves against your trade, losses also increase at the same pace. This makes risk management critical in intraday trading.
Margin Rules and Risk Control
As per SEBI regulations, brokers must collect margin upfront. If losses reach a certain level, the broker may close the position automatically or ask you to add more funds, known as a margin call. This system ensures losses do not exceed the available margin.
If a trader does not want the position to be squared off, they can add sufficient funds and convert the intraday trade into a delivery position. While this requires more capital, it allows the stock to be held beyond the trading day.
Options Trading vs. Intraday Trading
Here are the differences between option trading and intraday trading.
| Criteria | Options Trading | Intraday Trading |
|---|---|---|
|
Meaning |
Trading option contracts that give the right (not obligation) to buy or sell an asset at a fixed price before expiry |
Buying and selling stocks within the same trading day, with no overnight holding |
|
Instrument Traded |
Options (Call & Put) based on stocks, indices, or commodities |
Equity shares (cash market) |
|
Holding Period |
Can range from minutes to several days until expiry |
Must be closed within the same trading session |
|
Capital Requirement |
Option buying needs low capital; option selling requires high margin (SPAN + exposure) |
Requires margin upfront; capital depends on leverage provided |
|
Risk Profile |
Buyers: limited risk (premium paid), Sellers: high to unlimited risk depending on strategy |
Risk is limited to one day but amplified due to leverage |
|
Profit Potential |
Buyers can gain sharply if the move is strong. Sellers earn limited premium income |
Profits depend on intraday price movement and position size |
|
Role of Volatility |
Highly sensitive to volatility, time decay, and Greeks |
Less sensitive to volatility; mainly driven by price movement |
|
Time Decay (Theta) |
Works against option buyers as expiry approaches |
No time decay impact |
|
Complexity Level |
High – requires understanding of Greeks, volatility, and expiry |
Moderate – focused on price action and volume |
|
Broker Intervention |
Margin shortfall may lead to forced square-off |
Positions are auto-squared off near market close |
|
Best Suited For |
Experienced traders, hedgers, and strategy-based traders |
Short-term traders who prefer simplicity |
When Does Option Trading vs Intraday Make Sense?
Options trading suits different types of traders because it can be approached in two distinct ways.
- Buying options works well for traders who prefer a structured setup with clearly defined risk. Since the maximum loss is limited to the premium paid, it allows participation in market moves without constant screen monitoring. This approach is often preferred by traders who want flexibility and controlled downside risk.
- Selling options is generally suitable for experienced traders seeking a relatively steady income. Option sellers earn the premium upfront and profit when the market stays within an expected range. However, if the market moves sharply in the opposite direction, losses can be substantial. This strategy requires higher capital, margin availability, and a strong understanding of volatility, time decay, and Greeks.
- Intraday trading, in contrast, is better suited for traders who focus on quick opportunities within the same trading day. It demands fast decision-making and timely exits. While leverage can enhance returns, it can also magnify losses if trades move against expectations. Intraday trading tends to work best in clearly trending or volatile markets and requires strict discipline and risk control.
Final Words
Both option trading vs intraday trading offer short-term opportunities, but they require different mindsets and skill sets. As traders gain experience, their preferences often evolve, and many eventually combine these approaches based on market conditions, capital availability, and risk appetite.
Frequently Asked Questions on Option Trading vs Intraday Trading
Is options trading safer than intraday trading?
Neither is inherently safer. Option buying has limited risk, as losses are capped at the premium paid. Option selling carries high risk. Intraday trading also involves risk due to leverage, which can magnify losses quickly.
Can beginners start with intraday trading?
Beginners can start with intraday trading, but it requires discipline, quick decision-making, and strict risk control. Starting with small position sizes and clear stop-loss rules is essential.
Can an intraday trade be converted into delivery?
Yes. If sufficient funds are available to cover the full value of the shares, an intraday position can be converted into a delivery trade and held beyond market hours.
Which is more profitable, options trading or intraday trading?
Profitability depends on the trader’s skill, strategy, and market conditions. Intraday trading relies on short-term price moves, while options trading depends on direction, volatility, and time decay. There is no universal winner.
What is the biggest risk in intraday trading?
The biggest risk is over-leverage. Using high margins without proper stop-losses can lead to rapid and significant losses within a short time.
Can options be used for hedging instead of trading?
Yes. Options are widely used for hedging portfolios, helping investors protect against downside risk during volatile market conditions.
Happy investing and thank you for reading!
Disclaimer:
This website content is only for educational purposes, not investment advice. Before making any investment, it’s important to do your own research and be fully informed. Investing in the stock market includes risks, and you should carefully read the Risk Disclosure documents before proceeding. Please remember that past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, and due to market fluctuations, your investment goals may not always be achieved.
